Request an Exam Copy

The Mormon Mirage 4 of 5 by Latayne C. Scott

Categories Theology

A Former Member Looks at the Mormon Church Today

4 of 5: "It's All About the Story" 

Some Mormons have begun to publicly criticize me for "spending my life criticizing the LDS Church." It’s true that 5 of my 14 books are about Mormonism. However, that’s a fraction of my writings, and until this year the last book I published on the subject was 15 years ago. If I were the rabid dog nipping at the heel of their church, I counter, I certainly wasn’t very consistent. Thus when I felt a call to re-enter into the LDS thought world and examine its sea-changes, I did so with all the enthusiasm of Moses leaving the burning bush as I began to write The Mormon Mirage.

And, at the same time I was researching for this look at the Mormonism of the 21st century, I was also writing a novel, Latter-day Cipher.

Why would someone whose lifetime body of work was almost all non-fiction (books and hundreds of magazine articles and other short works) turn to writing a novel, one with a similar subject to some previous nonfiction books?

I confess: For many years I looked down on fiction writers – at least those who dealt with religious subjects – as having a much less rigorous task. But increasingly over the past years, I have felt a desire to explore ways new for me, of conveying truth through fiction.

One reason for this goes back all the way to a high school English class assignment and the impact it had on me. Though I have almost nothing in common with Upton Sinclair, the activist and writer of the early 20th century, I have never forgotten some of the images of his novel, The Jungle. Sinclair tried for years to write journalistic articles to raise public consciousness about the meatpacking industry, but not until he wrote his novel did people really pay attention (and thePure Food and Drug Act resulted from the outcry.)

We are living in a new world where people access information in twitters, on blogs, and through fiction and visual effects as much as through straight expository reading. Young people communicate with quotes from movies that make their conversations incomprehensible to those who haven’t seen the films. For a large segment of our population, it’s all about the story.

Jesus understood this, with the "single stabbing truth" of a parable, with the introduction of nameless people in daily scenarios, introduced by an almost-casual, "What do you think?"

But Jesus didn’t teach only in parables. He taught straight exposition, too. There has to be something behind every story, a framework that explains it all and doesn’t leave decisions to personal narratives and the force of emotions.

I had nothing to do with two publishers’ decisions to release a fiction and a nonfiction book about Mormonism within days of each other. But I’m thinking now that God wanted something up to date and heavily documented like The Mormon Mirage as a sort of backbone – a support and nerve center, so to speak – for the assertions of the characters in Latter-day Cipher.

Those who criticize what they call "anti-Mormon" writing say that the arguments are worn out, the Scriptural contrasts tired. For those whose hardened hearts have heard those "proofs" repeatedly and must resort to burying themselves in the slender hopes of convoluted Mormon-speak, it is undoubtedly so.

But for every Mormon who begins to confront the possibility that Mormonism could be wrong, it is as new as first sex. We feel as if we have invented it.

My novel, Latter-day Cipher, has sympathetically-portrayed LDS characters. They love Mormonism as I once did. They wrestle with these things as if they were Adams and Eves.

Every discovery of so-called "deprecated doctrines" is as personal as an inexplicable receipt found in a spouse’s wallet.

Most insurmountable of all for them is the deal-breaker element unique to Mormonism: the fact that for a faithful Mormon (such as I once was), something can be true and doctrinal for one generation, and then be repudiated in the next.

In the language of Representational Research, such actions by a church are not just changes of representations, they are the wholesaling of facts.

Click here for the Mormon Mirage table of contents.

Scottl  Latayne C. Scott was a faithful and happy Mormon for ten years, attending Brigham Young University on writing scholarship and working as a staff member for two of BYU’s weekly magazines. She is the author of thirteen published books, including The Mormon Mirage, Why We Left Mormonism and After Mormonism, What? She has also published articles and poems in secular magazines and in major Christian magazines. She is the recipient of Pepperdine University’s "Distinguished Christian Service Award" for "creative Christian writing." She is a representational thinker and a full-time writer, living in New Mexico. Her Web sites are and

Influential Books and Authors: Craig S. Keener on the Power of God's Word
Influential Books and Authors: Craig S. Keener on the Power of God's Word Each week in Influential Books and Authors we hear from a noted scholar on the author(s) and book(s) that have bee...
Your form could not be submitted. Please check errors and resubmit.

Thank you!
Sign up complete.

Subscribe to the Blog Get expert commentary on biblical languages, fresh explorations in theology, hand-picked book excerpts, author videos, and info on limited-time sales.
By submitting your email address, you understand that you will receive email communications from HarperCollins Christian Publishing (501 Nelson Place, Nashville, TN 37214 USA) providing information about products and services of HCCP and its affiliates. You may unsubscribe from these email communications at any time. If you have any questions, please review our Privacy Policy or email us at This form is protected by reCAPTCHA.